Woman in a blue patterned dress working on a laptop at a kitchen island, with a mug and phone nearby.

Buyer's Financing Fell Through in Madison? What Happens Now

What happens if a buyer's financing falls through in Madison?

Under the WB-11 Residential Offer to Purchase, the buyer has until the loan commitment deadline in the offer to deliver a copy of their written loan commitment. If the lender rejects the loan, the buyer has to promptly give the seller written notice with a copy of the lender's rejection letter, and the deal generally ends with the earnest money returned. If the buyer simply misses the deadline, the offer doesn't end on its own: the seller gets the right to terminate in writing, up until the seller actually receives the commitment. Extensions are done with a WB-40 Amendment, and both sides have to agree.

By Cait Berry | November 19, 2026

It's one of the worst calls to get in the middle of a transaction. Everything is on track, the inspection is done, moving trucks are booked, and then: "the lender says the loan isn't going to work."

If you're the buyer, you're panicking about your earnest money and the house. If you're the seller, you're wondering whether you're stuck waiting or whether you can put the home back on the market.

The good news is that the Wisconsin offer spells out what happens. Here's how I walk my clients through it.

How the financing contingency actually works

Most offers in Dane County include the WB-11's Financing Commitment Contingency. Three pieces matter most:

  • The loan commitment deadline. The offer sets a number of days after acceptance. By that day, the buyer is supposed to deliver a copy of the lender's written loan commitment to the seller.
  • The buyer's duty to apply promptly. The buyer has to apply for the loan right away and work in good faith to get it. Sitting on the application, or making a big purchase that blows up your debt ratio, isn't protected.
  • Written direction. The buyer reviews the commitment and directs, in writing, that it be delivered to the seller. Your lender can't just send it over on its own.

One detail surprises a lot of buyers: a commitment can count even if it has conditions on it. Once you deliver it, the financing contingency is generally satisfied. If there's a condition you're not sure you can meet, talk to your lender and your agent before that commitment goes to the seller.

The appraisal contingency is separate. Delivering a loan commitment doesn't waive it, which I covered in my post on what to do when the appraisal comes in low.

Scenario 1: The lender denies the loan

If the loan is rejected, the buyer needs to promptly deliver written notice to the seller, along with a copy of the lender's rejection letter or other evidence the loan isn't available.

What happens next depends on how the offer was written, but in most Madison deals:

  • The offer ends, and the buyer's earnest money is generally returned under the contingency.
  • The seller may have a short window to offer seller financing, depending on how the offer's financing section was completed. In practice, that rarely happens in our price range.
  • Both sides sign a cancellation and mutual release so the earnest money can be disbursed.

The key word is "promptly." A buyer who knows the loan is dead and stays quiet for a week is creating risk for themselves.

When a denial is the buyer's problem

The contingency protects buyers from a lender saying no. It doesn't protect against choices the buyer made. Changing jobs, financing a car, opening new credit, or not sending documents to the lender can turn a financing problem into a breach. If you're mid-transaction, don't make any financial moves without calling your lender first.

Scenario 2: The commitment is just late

This one is more common than a denial. The underwriter needs one more document, a condo questionnaire is slow, or the appraisal came in late. The deadline passes and there's no commitment.

Here's what most people don't realize: the offer doesn't automatically end when the deadline passes. Instead, the seller gets a choice.

  • The seller can terminate by delivering written notice to the buyer, but only before the seller actually receives the buyer's loan commitment.
  • The seller can wait. If the commitment shows up before the seller sends a termination notice, the contingency is satisfied and the deal moves forward.
  • Or both sides can extend the deadline with a WB-40 Amendment.

For sellers, this is a judgment call. If the buyer's lender says "clear to close by Friday" and you have no backup offer, terminating rarely makes sense. If the buyer has gone silent and you have another buyer interested, it's a different conversation.

For buyers: watch your deadline. If you can see you won't make it, ask for an extension before it passes, not after.

What happens to the earnest money

When a buyer ends the deal properly under the financing contingency, the earnest money generally goes back to the buyer. When both sides agree, that happens through a signed cancellation and release.

When they don't agree, the money stays put. In Wisconsin, the broker or title company holding the earnest money can't just pick a side. There's a formal process with written notice before any disbursement, and some disputes end up in small claims court. I walk through that process in earnest money in Madison: how much and when you can lose it.

What buyers should do right now

  1. Ask your lender exactly what's missing. Is it a true denial or a condition you can still meet?
  2. Ask about other loan options. A different program, a co-signer, or a different lender may still work. The contingency lets you accept a loan on different terms if you choose.
  3. Tell your agent immediately so the seller hears it from the right person, with the right notice.
  4. Don't miss your deadline. Either deliver the commitment, deliver a rejection notice, or get a written extension.

The best protection happens before you write an offer. A full pre-approval, not a quick pre-qualification, catches most problems early. Here's the difference between pre-approval and pre-qualification in Madison.

What sellers should do right now

  1. Get the facts in writing. Ask for the lender's letter or a written update through the agents.
  2. Decide whether to extend, wait, or terminate. Each one has a cost. Waiting costs time; terminating puts you back on the market in November or December.
  3. Line up a backup. If there was another interested buyer, a secondary offer can step in if this one ends.
  4. Don't go back on market informally. Until the current offer is properly ended, you're still under contract.

If the closing date itself is slipping, I covered extensions and rate locks in what happens when a Madison closing is delayed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a buyer back out if their loan is denied in Wisconsin? Yes, if the offer includes the WB-11 financing contingency and the buyer promptly gives the seller written notice with a copy of the lender's rejection. The earnest money is generally returned once both sides sign a release.

Does the offer end automatically if the loan commitment deadline passes? No. Under the WB-11, a missed deadline gives the seller the right to terminate by written notice, but only until the seller actually receives the loan commitment. The parties can also extend the deadline with a WB-40 Amendment.

Does a loan commitment with conditions satisfy the financing contingency? Generally, yes. Once a buyer delivers a commitment, even one with conditions, the financing contingency is usually satisfied. Buyers should review conditions with their lender before directing the commitment to the seller.

Will a buyer lose earnest money if financing falls through? Not if they end the deal properly under the financing contingency and on time. Buyers risk their earnest money when they miss deadlines, waived the contingency, or caused the denial through their own choices.

Can a seller accept another offer while waiting on the buyer's financing? A seller can accept a secondary offer that becomes primary only if the first offer ends. Until the current offer is properly terminated, the seller is still under contract with the first buyer.

The bottom line

A financing problem doesn't have to turn into a lost house or a lost deposit. The WB-11 gives both sides a clear path: buyers deliver a commitment or a rejection on time, and sellers decide whether to wait, extend, or terminate in writing. Every situation is different, so get the facts from the lender before anyone makes a move.

Your Madison Insiders

Financing hit a snag on your Madison home?

Let's look at your deadlines and your options together.

Schedule a Call with Cait

Get the Buyer's Guide

About Cait Berry

Cait Berry is the founder and team lead of Insiders Realty with REAL Broker, LLC, serving buyers and sellers across Dane County. A sixth-generation Madisonian and full-time agent since 2012, she helps relocating families, move-up buyers and sellers, and first-time buyers make confident moves in the Madison market. She’s also a business coach for real estate agents with Tom Ferry.

This post is general information about the standard Wisconsin offer form, not legal advice. Your offer's terms control, and forms are revised from time to time, so review your specific contract with your agent or a real estate attorney.

Written by Cait Berry, Insiders Realty. Your local Madison real estate expert helping you live, work, and play right here in Dane County.

relax

Let us use our expertise in the industry, paired with our local insiders knowledge to take all the stress of real estate off your hands, so that you can truly enjoy the process.
Follow Us